Advertisements
T+L: Smarter Connections for 21st Century Learners

BoardBuzz

Straight Talk on Tobacco
Most people assume that all schools are completely tobacco free - it just seems to make too much sense not to be true! Unfortunately, the truth is more complicated than that, and according to the latest available school health data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, only 58 percent of states, 55.4 percent of districts, and 63.6 percent of schools prohibit all tobacco use in all locations at all times. So, there is plenty of room for improvement in making all schools tobacco-free! Join NSBA school health experts, Karen Lewis and Brenda Greene for an online discussion March 31, at 12:45 ET, to get the full scoop on tobacco free schools and to learn more about what school districts can do to make campuses tobacco free. You can submit a question in advance or log in to the discussion as it happens.

Join us here at the scheduled hour for a lively dialogue on this timely education topic.

A school board member from Kentucky asks:

I heard that the 2008 NSBA Delegate Assembly passed a policy urging local school boards to adopt comprehensive tobacco-free schools policy. What's that all about?
Karen Lewis writes:

Welcome to our online chat on tobacco. Thanks for asking a question. Many people think that all schools are completely tobacco free, and are surprised to find that is not the case. The Delegate Assembly decided to encourage local school boards to support tobacco use prevention, as it is the leading cause of preventable death in the US. Tobacco-free school policies can contribute significantly to preventing young people from starting to use tobacco products.
An individual from Warrenton, NC asks:

Aren't all schools already tobacco-free? Isn't there a federal law prohibiting smoking in schools?
Karen Lewis writes:

Perhaps surprisingly, all schools are not completely tobacco free. Many people don%u2019t realize that the federal Pro Children Act of 1990 does not mandate completely tobacco free school environments. It applies only to federally funded, indoor facilities that are used by children %u2013 not outdoor areas at a school, or staff lounges. It also applies only to tobacco products that are smoked, not to spit tobacco or other products creatively marketed by the tobacco industry.
An individual from Lincoln, Montana asks:

Everyone knows that smoking is bad for you. Hasn't the problem basically been solved already?
Karen Lewis writes:

Many people are surprised to know that tobacco use is still the leading preventable cause of death in the U.S. Approximately 400, 000 die from the effects of tobacco use each year, not counting the additional 25,000-75,000 who die each year from exposure to secondhand smoke. Tobacco use kills more people each year than alcohol, illegal drugs, homicides, and suicides combined. The tobacco industry needs to replace the smokers who die or quit each year. To this end, they spend billions marketing to kids. More than 4,000 kids under the age of 18 try tobacco every day, and 1,100 of those become regular smokers. Many young people don%u2019t realize that spit tobacco is also addictive and causes cancer. This problem is far from solved.
A parent from Winter Park, FL asks:

We haven't allowed student smoking in more than 2 decades. Doesn't that mean our school is tobacco-free?
Karen Lewis writes:

To be completely tobacco free, no tobacco use of any kind can be used at any time by anyone on school property. Adults are important role models for children and youth. Surveys indicate that kids are well aware of which teachers and coaches use tobacco. Allowing these role models to use tobacco on school property gives an implicit endorsement of tobacco use, in addition to sending a "do as I say, not as I do" message to kids. One strategy employed by the tobacco industry to promote smoking among youth is to present it as "an adult custom." Naturally, children of all ages aspire to take on adult customs as signs of maturity. Allowing adult tobacco use on school property plays into this tobacco industry strategy. In addition, about 14 percent of boys use spit tobacco. While harder to detect than smoked tobacco, spit tobacco is also addictive and can be just as lethal.
A school board member from Walnut Grove, CA asks:

As a new school board member, how do I know what to include in a comprehensive tobacco free schools policy that our board is developing?
Karen Lewis writes:

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention%u2019s Division of Adolescent and School Health set out guidelines in 1994 for comprehensive tobacco-free schools policies. The guidelines recommend that a tobacco-free environment exists if the state, school district, or school has a policy prohibiting cigarette, cigar and pipe smoking and spit tobacco use by students, faculty, staff and visitors at all times in school buildings, on school grounds, in school buses or other vehicles used to transport students, and at off campus, school-sponsored events. Many state school boards associations offer model tobacco use prevention policies. Ask your state association if they have a model policy, and if it aligns with CDC recommendations. Also, the National Association of State Boards of Education (NASBE) has a newly revised Tobacco chapter featuring model tobacco free schools policies in its publication, Fit, Healthy, and Ready to Learn. Contact NSBA%u2019s School Health Programs for additional technical assistance on tobacco use prevention policies, at schoolhealth@nsba.org.
An individual from Front Royal, VA asks:

What does NSBA have on the books regarding tobacco use policy?
Karen Lewis writes:

The 2008 Delegate Assembly approved a policy encouraging local school boards to adopt comprehensive tobacco free schools policies. Our School Health Programs department can provide information, tools and technical assistance to local school boards on policy development and make sure that school boards contact their respective state associations for state-specific assistance. Moreover, NSBA staff can put districts in touch with state education agency and health departments that can be of assistance. In addition, at the national level, NSBA is working with multiple organizations that have state affiliates working towards tobacco free schools. Contact School Health Programs for more information at schoolhealth@nsba.org.
An individual from Colorado asks:

Currently, Colorado has a Tobacco-Free Schools Law in the state, prohibiting tobacco-use by students, staff, and visitors at all times on school grounds and at school-sponsored events. The state laws do not currently include prohibiting youth possession of tobacco products. The Fit, Healthy, and Ready to Learn model policy does include prohibiting youth tobacco possession on school grounds. What would be your recommendation for school district policy and consequences regarding youth tobacco possession on school grounds?
Brenda Z. Greene writes:

This may be an opportunity for the school dist5rict to partner with its families, community agencies, and community based organizations to determine what is needed locally. If state law does not prohibit going beyond existing legislation, then these entities could work together to tackle this issue in a constructive way. In this way, the local school district could make sure that the consequences of youth possession would not be punitive and result in kids being out of school, which would be detrimental to their academic and physical well-being. Rather, the consequences could be educational and motivational, such as researching the health effects of tobacco use or volunteering at a hospital or hospice. Consider contacting your state school boards association and/or your state education agency to find out which districts in Colorado may have already taken this step.
A school board member from Omaha, Nebraska asks:

Schools are asked to do so much. My priority is to raise student achievement. Shouldn't tobacco use prevention be a responsibility of families and the community?
Brenda Z. Greene writes:

Certainly, there is a shared responsibility to help young people be healthy, but there are reasons and ways for schools to contribute. Importantly, student health and student achievement are closely linked. Healthy students learn better. Students who miss school from an asthma episode (asthma is the leading cause of school absences, and can be triggered by secondhand smoke)or because they have been caught using tobacco are at a significant disadvantage. Schools with comprehensive tobacco free schools policies, and schools that address tobacco use violations with non-punitive measures (such as assigning research on the effects of tobacco use or requiring students to participate in a tobacco cessation program instead of suspending a student for using tobacco) can help kids to stay in school and stay healthy.
An individual from Seattle, WA asks:

My state has passed a Clean Indoor Air law, banning smoking in any enclosed place, including bars, and restaurants. Problem solved for my schools, right?
Karen Lewis writes:

While 23 states have passed Clean Indoor Air laws, the laws may not address school tobacco policies directly. Check your school tobacco policy against any statewide law to see that they align and are consistent with CDC recommendations. In addition, make sure your school or district tobacco policy includes provisions regarding spit tobacco, which is not covered by clean indoor air laws. As with any policy, having a system that monitors implementation and the effectiveness of the policy is essential to ensure that the goal of comprehensive tobacco free schools is achieved.
An individual from Ivanhoe, Minnesota asks:

Do school policies really have an effect on tobacco use among our students?
Karen Lewis writes:

Studies have found that schools with consistently enforced no-tobacco-use policies are more likely to have lower rates of student smoking than comparable schools without such policies. A tobacco-free school policy is the cornerstone of a comprehensive school based tobacco use prevention program.
A parent from Wisconsin asks:

Ok, I agree that kids shouldn't smoke at school. But why can't adults use tobacco in faculty lounges or outside the school door?
Karen Lewis writes:

Adults are important role models for children and youth. Surveys indicate that kids are well aware of which teachers and coaches use tobacco. Allowing these role models to use tobacco on school property gives an implicit endorsement of tobacco use, in addition to sending a "do as I say, not as I do" message to kids. It clearly conflicts with tobacco use prevention messages taught in health education and other instructional programs. One strategy employed by the tobacco industry to promote smoking among youth is to present it as "an adult custom." Naturally, children of all ages aspire to take on adult customs as signs of maturity. Allowing adult tobacco use on school property plays into this tobacco industry strategy.
A school board member from Kentucky asks:

Where can I get more information about revising school tobacco use policies?
Karen Lewis writes:

Check with your state school boards association to see if they have a policy services division that can provide a model tobacco policy for your district or school. In addition, you can contact NSBA School Health Programs for information on their Tobacco Use Prevention Project, at 703-535-1618 or SchoolHealth@nsba.org. The CDC guidelines on tobacco use prevention through schools are available at http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00026213.htm.